A few days ago, I was talking to my best friend Soohyun when he told me that people don’t care if you’re mysterious. In response, my jaw dropped to the floor.
I’m a Pinterest frequenter, and if you’re unfamiliar with the platform, it’s filled with millions of ‘aesthetic photos,’ and all the latest trends. You’ll often find pictures of girls with their hair up in a claw clip while wearing pretty dresses. Pinterest is infamous for its romanization of life, but what makes Pinterest different from most other social media platforms is that it’s mostly anonymous. Pinterest is meant to be catered to you, filled with people and places you don’t know. It learns from what you save and then puts photos that you might like on your feed.
You don’t see your friend’s selfies or homecoming photos, it is simply filled with your interests. It’s the most popular place to find photos for a vision board, and you’ll often find that the faces of the people themselves are hidden, or at least not the focus of the photo. In addition, it’s difficult to find where a photo is from, especially because some images are reposted by many different creators. Although it’s filled with influencer pictures, you’ll rarely find people with a loyal Pinterest following.
So why does Pinterest relate to being a “mysterious indie girl,” and what does it mean to be one?
Pinterest is littered with mysterious indie girls. I consider it the mysterious indie girl hub spot. But to figure out what this really means, I’ve created step-by-step instructions on how to bring your mysterious aura to its full potential.
1. Find a record player, corded earbuds, or over-the-ear headphones. Preferably all three.
This is an essential part of the process and the beginning of the characterization of a mysterious indie girl. In public, when you’re listening to music, people can’t help but wonder: Who is that girl? What is she listening to? How is she so mysterious? And other such remarks. You’ve created your own bubble, one that they may be unable to figure out.
Additionally, you need to find your way to a record shop. Rifle through dozens of sections, of bands you’ve never heard of and may never listen to. Although it’s an expensive hobby, listening to vinyls in your room will increase your mystery. Why aren’t you just using a Bluetooth speaker? That’s what they have to figure out.
Queue up your indie bands, and you get brownie points if you choose “underground music” when the artist has at least seven million monthly listeners on Spotify (I am very guilty of this one).
2. Buy a claw clip.
As previously mentioned earlier, Pinterest, Instagram, and Tiktok all have an abundance of claw clip styles and wearers. Although I consider it the evolution of the messy bun era, it’s a really cute hairstyle that completes the mystery. Currently, I’m working on this step, but I can’t seem to perfect the look. Honestly though, I love the effortless beauty of the claw clips. It’s simple, it’s elegant, and I love to see it.
3. Take a visit to your local thrift store.
Another mysterious indie girl spot includes secondhand stores. The women in there are always styled up, and I make sure to wear my best outfits in case I run into a mysterious indie girl. Here, you can find unique and “vintage” pieces, and layering in your outfits will soon become your best friend. As you go through the racks, remember how mysterious you look in an unfamiliar place, and have fun looking for more mysterious pieces.
In all seriousness, thrifting is a good practice, and a fun way to reduce the effects of fast fashion, so I would highly recommend trying it. Let me know if you want to go, and I’ll come with you!
4. Wear brown, black, and as many neutral colors as possible.
Part of the mysterious indie girl look includes oversized pants and jackets, all in muted colors. If you scroll through Pinterest, it won’t take long for inspiration to spark. In my opinion, neutrals can never go wrong, and it’s fun to make outfits this way. Who is she? These neutral colors are really hiding something, the mystery is undeniable!
5. Read.
Reading, and studying, all add to the mysterious indie girl image. You could be on your phone, talking to friends, but no, you’re different, and that’s intriguing. What is she reading? I want to know more! Romanticize studying, it’s fun!
6. Side profile pictures.
The final, most important step. If you’re wearing headphones, you must take a side profile photo. It can be a mirror or taken by someone else, but once you get a side profile headphones photo, you have made it as an indie girl. I haven’t had mine yet, but it is truly a right of passage.
I hope that with these photos and instructions, you have all you need to understand what mysterious indie girls are. And I hope this proves Soohyun wrong. However, you will never understand a mysterious indie girl (because they are mysterious).
How is she so mysterious? I wish I could know more. I can’t, but I wish I could.
Hola Izzy!
First off, let me just say: I adore your writing style. It is so effortlessly entertaining – you write exactly as I imagine a mysterious indie girl would write.
I must admit, I have tried to use Pinterest on multiple occasions, but I’ve never been able to commit to the platform. I feel overwhelmed when I open the app; the sudden rush of pictures quickly swallows me whole. In a moment of sensory overload, I don’t know where to look or what to click, and then, flustered, the app gets deleted. After reading your blog and seeing all the aesthetic pictures, however, I’m definitely inspired to try my hand at Pinterest once more.
As you point out, I think it is interesting, at least from an anthropological point of view, to consider Gen. Z’s romanticization of life. From the Tumblr of the 2010s to the TikTok of today, our timelines are defined by aesthetic collages of life’s simple pleasures – clothing, sunsets, etc. Such is a stark contrast to the unique era of climate change, political polarization, and economic instability we have grown up in, and although perhaps I am being overly cynical, I can’t help but wonder if we’ve cultivated this “mysterious indie girl” aesthetic over the last decade as some sort of coping mechanism.
Wouldn’t it be easier to pretend that we spend our time perusing the vinyl section at Barnes and Nobles rather than doomscrolling social media?
Anyway, this got dark real fast. I am not immune to the allure of the mysterious indie girl aesthetic; I plan on going thrifting for a bit over the weekend. As much as I know things are not okay, for now, I pretend that they are.
Estimada Compañera,
Many thanks for this in-depth guide. This pursuit is very real, and I am horrified to hear of Soohyun’s behavior. My jaw joins yours on the floor.
As you know, I am a fellow Pinterest enthusiast. Perhaps I have a legitimate addiction to compartmentalizing images that I find online (currently 17,785 saved), or perhaps I am just a mysterious indie girl.
Throughout my countless hours on this app, I, too, am familiar with the motif of the mysterious indie girl and approve of your summary. The recent trend of headphones makes me want them more than ever, and the record shop photo shoots from my instagram and Pinterest feeds are all too familiar.
In regards to the claw clip, I started wearing them in seventh grade due to the influence of my mother- she was an O.G. My friends made fun of me at the time, but the recent popularity makes me reflect on that.
The element of mystery is essential- so close yet so far. Reading in particular contributes to this. So unique, so correct.
It’s ironic how chasing quirkiness makes you unoriginal.
But this blog was very real, and I highly anticipate your next masterpiece.
Izzy, your blog topic was so unique and I had a lot of fun reading it. I am also a fan of the mysterious girl vibes and have been guilty of trying to emulate it in certain scenarios. I have been a Pinterest user since sixth grade and have mainly used it to find fashion/outfit inspiration as well as short memes of something funny. I will admit that when I was younger I wanted to start posting on Pinterest; the promise of anonymity seemed to offer the solution to me wanting to share my outfits with others while protecting my identity. I’m curious, if you were asked to rate yourself from 1-10 with 10 being the most mysterious girl alive, how would you score yourself? I also wanted to let you know that your explanation of how each specific action or trait made you mysterious was very enlightening and engaging. The logic behind wearing headphones in public and creating an actual mystery by having people actually wonder what you’re listening to is very compelling. I wish you all the best in your endeavors to become more of a mysterious, indie girl. Hopefully one of your blogs in the future will feature your side profile picture with the chunky headphones and extreme aesthetics.